Sean Roberts asked in a comment:
Gordon,
I'm curious how you, as a supporter of Opus Dei, respond to the charges of the Opus Dei Awareness Group (their link is in the slate article).
I've read some of that stuff; if you've read one book you've read 'em all. To be honest I think that 60% of it is people who have an axe to grind, 35% is misunderstanding, and 5% is, perhaps, based in some truth that doesn't represent the Work as a whole.
Yes, the Work encourages people to bring others into contact with the Work, and with Catholicism in general. That's hardly noteworthy, since in living out our own call to holiness we should be trying to bring them to Christ. The resources of Opus Dei can be very helpful to people trying to grow in their faith; they are of enormous value.
Some people claim the Work is "secretive." That has not been my experience. It is true the Work doesn't run commercials and it doesn't place ads; people usually come into contact with Opus Dei through someone who is already in contact with it. That is not really surprising, or it shouldn't be. In any case it is, to me, indicative of the approach of Opus Dei that we should evangelize through personal relationships, one-on-one, just as Christ did. After all, Christ loves each of us as we are, a unique person -- we are not numbers to Christ, we are individuals to be loved and cherished. The workings of Opus Dei are not secret, though the affairs of individual members are, since they are their private concerns.
Many people seem to misunderstand Opus Dei because they think it's a religious order, or some kind of lay movement similar to what they have seen before. It is not. The fact that it is a personal prelature (currently the only one in the Church) is because it needed a structure unlike anything else in the Church. Consider that there are some 2,000 Opus Dei priests for 80,000 members (plus a gazillion cooperators like myself). That means that members of Opus Dei can and do get plenty of advice and spiritual direction. To be honest, I think that's why the OD priests are such good confessors; they have a lot of insight into the ordinary problems of everyday life that many priests don't get due to the huge numbers they must deal with.
Some claim that Opus Dei is wealthy. These are usually the same kinds of people who talk about the Vatican's amazing, untold wealth :-) and it's about as likely. Yes, OD is able to do a lot -- due to the generosity of its members and its supporters and benefactors. This is hardly surprising. Personally, I have never, EVER been asked, in the 8+ years I've been a cooperator, about my financial support, or to give more. To be honest I give very little, much less than I ought (mea culpa!). I
have been reminded that I have made a commitment to pray for the Work -- but that is a commitment I freely made (and would make again in a heartbeat) and it was in the context of the usual examination of conscience we do as cooperators.
Let's see, what's the rest of the list? Opus Dei is 'conservative'. Well, I'm not sure what that means to people who say it. Some people undoubtedly think OD is not 'conservative' enough because its priests say the current ("Novus Ordo") Mass in English. The truth is that OD is orthodox, committed to the Pope and the Magisterium, and faithful to the teachings of the Church (all of them). OD is also cooperative with local bishops -- my pastor, who used to be the chancellor for our diocese, said to me once that he had never had any problems with Opus Dei (an Opus Dei priest came once a month to give spiritual direction to priests in the diocese as well as do our evening of recollection) -- that they always asked first and were cooperative.
Some people are claiming that Bl. Josemaria is being canonized too quickly. Well, it's true that it has not taken a long time -- but complaints on that score (why would anyone complain about a canonization? It's a blessing!) should be addressed to the Vatican that is authorizing it, not to the Work.
That's about all I can think of to say, except -- try it out for yourself. Examine the fruits of the Work for yourself. Go to a retreat, attend an evening of recollection, read some of Bl. Josemaria's works for yourself. Many of them can be found
here. There's plenty of information at the Opus Dei
website. I think you will find it refreshing and helpful, but if you don't that's fine. I am positive that whether you find Opus Dei to be your path or not, you will find no basis for the kind of stuff coming from the ODAN.