The liturgical wars continue -- Liturgical changes shake up Catholic churches. Of course, kneeling at the consecration has been "the rule" since Vatican II. Either the bishop of the diocese in question (Richmond) explictly gave people permission to stand, or, more likely, the parishes in question were disobeying the rules. So now that the rules are being reiterated some people think they are new! I love this quote:
But the Rev. Thomas Quinlan, the priest at Church of the Holy Family in Virginia Beach, denounced the new guidelines.
``If I kneel down, am I holier and closer to Jesus? Get real!'' Quinlan said the changes would undermine an important principle of Vatican II -- encouraging the active participation of lay people in worship.
What hubris! Evidently Fr. Quinlan thinks it's okay to disparage guidelines that were established by the US bishops in 1970. I really fail to understand how kneeling discourages active participation. Gordon 10:32 AM
I saw Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers on Friday. I thought it was really good, but I was a little disappointed in some of the liberties that were taken with the story. There seemed to be a lot more of them than in the first movie -- that is, in the first movie, there was a fair amount of material that was deleted, but little was outright changed/made up. There was a lot more in this movie, and most of the changes didn't seem to me to be improvements or to make a lot of sense from the point of view of the story. Still, it's most definitely worth seeing, probably several times. Gordon 9:32 AM
My friend Maria and her family arrived today from Dallas and they came over to say Hi briefly. As we were chatting we were listening to a recording of Messiah. During one of the arias, Maria suddenly exclaims, "That's not right! There's no Bflat in that passage!" So of course we had to dig out the music and listen to the passage on the CD again. Of course she was right. It's cool to have friends like that. Gordon 12:23 AM
Sunday, December 22, 2002
I attended the Arizona Repertory Singers Christmas Concert today. They are a group of about 35 singers, in their 19th season. Here's what the program looked like:
The First Nowell
O Nata Lux - Lux Aeterna
Carols of the Nativity
- It Came Upon the Midnight Clear
- Infant Holy, Infant Lowly
- Angels We Have Heard
There Is No Rose of Such Virtue
A Christmas Carol
The Ship Carol
The Blessed Son of God - Hodie Angel Alleluias
arr. Stephen Paulus
Norman dello Joio
Ralph Vaughan Williams
Chanson Joyeuse de Noél
Hark! The Herald Angels Sing
Jesus, Jesus, Rest Your Head
Deck the Hall
Winds Through the Olive Trees
O Magnum Mysterium
Out of the Orient Crystal Skies
Carol of the Bells
Francois Auguste Gevaert
arr. Stephen Paulus
arr. John Rutter
arr. Richard Zgodava
arr. Harry Simeone
All in all it was an okay concert. Some parts were pretty nice, but others seemed to lack heart. The choir sings pretty well but I'm not to sure about the choice of music -- I'd have preferred weightier stuff. Gordon 11:57 PM
Saturday, December 21, 2002
I have been working on my Christmas cards tonight. As I've gotten older my list has gotten pretty amazingly long. Of course there's my family, including aunts, uncles, cousins, etc. There's also a long list of friends from college and even high school. There are several clergy on the list. One of them is Fr. Tom DeMan, a Dominican who was chaplain at the University of Arizona Newman Center when I was an undergraduate. Hard to believe Fr. Tom has been a Dominican for more than 40 years! In writing his card I decided to write a brief note. I post it here in hopes that it will encourage others to find ways to thank the priests in their lives this Christmas.
Dear Fr. Tom,
Thanks for your great letter, and congratulations (is that the right word?) on your "retirement".
I wanted to say "thanks" though that seems very inadequate for the gratitude I feel.
I have not always agreed with you, either when I was at UA or since then -- but I've always respected and admired you. In the 4.5 years I spent with you at Arizona I learned to think about my faith -- that it was okay to question because there were answers. I experienced God working in and through you in very direct ways. And of course I'll never forget how you were there for me when my mother passed away.
Thank you for being open to God, to being willing to serve Him when so many choose not to.
We spent some time in rehearsal this morning working on O Holy Night. We have a soloist who will be singing the first verse in French and then we'll continue in English. I'd never seen the French words before.
C'est l'heure solennelle
Où l'Homme Dieu descendit jusqu'à nous
Pour effacer la tache originelle
Et de son père arrêter le courroux.
Le mode entier tressaille d'espérance
En cette nuit qui lui donne un sauveur.
Peuple à genoux,
Attends ta délivrance!
Voici le Rédempteur!
Voici le Rédempteur!
O holy night! The stars are brightly shining
It is the night of the dear Savior's birth!
Long lay the world in sin and error pining
Till he appear'd and the soul felt its worth.
A thrill of hope the weary world rejoices
For yonder breaks a new and glorious morn!
Fall on your knees
Oh hear the angel voices
Oh night divine
Oh night when Christ was born
Oh night divine
Oh night divine
All I can say is, where the heck did the English translation come from? It's nice poetry, sure, but theologically it's incredibly watered down. The original speaks of the God-Man coming to remove the blot of original sin. I always thought it a bit much to claim the night itself was divine. "night divine" and "holy night" don't appear in the French text at all, and there's no reference to the angels or their voices, either. Gordon 5:31 PM
For over two millennia, Christmas has carried the message that God is with us, and because he is with us we can always live in hope. The world we live in is very different from the world of ancient Bethlehem. Our need for that hope is still unchanged. In all the challenges and dangers of our day, we still seek the promise of peace on Earth.
Whether you are a Republican or a Democrat, please pray for our President, our Congress, and all our leaders. Gordon 5:24 PM
I got my Christmas tree today, a 6.5 foot Douglas fir, from the tree lot run by the world-famous Tucson Arizona Boys Chorus. I love Christmas trees and I've never understood the desire of people to have a fake one. A real one smells so good and just makes the room complete. Growing up we never put our Christmas tree up too early and we usually kept it until New Years Day. I've kept that tradition. So I'll put it up tonight and probably put lights on it, then tomorrow and Monday more decorations. Gordon 3:25 PM
Friday, December 20, 2002
In case you think academics don't care about what's really important -- a study suggests Playboy models losing hourglass figures. Anyone else think the researchers really suffered to do this study? Seriously, though, it's not clear to me whether these changes represent some amount of models looking more like real people or not.
In 2000, a British Medical Association report found that in 1950 the average woman weighed about eight-and-a-half stone and had a 24-inch waist. Now, she is more than 10 stone, with a 32-inch waist. (N.B. 1 stone = 14 pounds)
Sounds about right to me; the huge proportion of people in the developed world who are overweight would seem to explain this pretty readily. Gordon 4:25 PM
A man and woman ought to experience sexual intercourse as a mutual giving and receiving in open self-surrender to each other; it is a kind of communication—the language of the body—a sign of sincere giving of self and sincere acceptance of the other's gift, and of their mutual opening up to God's gift of life. This kind of giving and receiving without reserve requires the foundation of stable, permanent love.
Thus, considered as communication, intercourse outside marriage and contraceptive intercourse both are lies told with bodies; the two parties do not truly give and receive openly and unconditionally but only use each other for pleasure. They do not say with their bodies, and from their hearts, what they speak with their lips. Indeed, all sexual sins are at their heart sins of dishonesty. Gordon 11:15 AM
Apparently the first miracle is a young Indian Hindu woman who was spontaneously healed from a stomach tumor. The beatification will be October 19th of 2003. Gordon 9:27 AM
Thursday, December 19, 2002
More good news! I weighed myself today, and I've lost 2 lbs. since 12/9. I'm at 223 now. My midterm goal is 200 lbs, I'm thinking I might make that by summer. My ultimate goal is 180 lbs. but that could be pretty difficult; it's what I weighed in college more or less. On the other hand my coworker Jacquie and I have agreed to up our daily walk from twice around the building complex to three times starting 1/2, so that will help a little.
Update: Also, when I got home tonight the results of my latest blood work were back -- my cholesterol is down to 196 (HDL 37, LDL 116), and my trigylcerides have declined substantially, to 211. Way to go Gordon! (pats self on back) Gordon 3:36 PM
Tonight I went Christmas caroling with friends in Winterhaven. Winterhaven is a neighborhood in Tucson that was built in the 1950s and has always been known for its spectacular Christmas displays; it's a Tucson tradition. We were there from 6:30 to 8:30 or so. It was cold out by Tucson standards -- we should have a hard freeze tonight which happens probably less than 15 nights a year. This is the third year I've organized caroling. We had kind of a small turnout this year, just five of us -- myself, Peter from Collegium Musicum, Kieran and her husband Ernie (also from Collegium) and Amber Lee. So we had two basses, one tenor, one alto and a soprano; they were all strong voices and good readers so we were able to do a couple of more challenging things (Carol of the Bells, Victoria's O Magnum Mysterium). We also read through Deck the Halls in 7/8 but it's not ready for prime time yet :-). It was a fun evening and our music was appreciated. Gordon 11:50 PM
Communal Penance Service December 18, 2002
Gathering Song: Remember Your Love (OCP #682)
Psalm: Create In Me (Psalm 51) (OCP #766)
Gospel Acclamation: Advent Alleluia (OCP)
Fr. John was mistaken, we did not have the bishops. We did have Bishop Francis Quinn, retired bishop of Sacramento, who resides in the Tucson area much of the year. While I was there I got snookered into cantoring for 11 a.m. Mass on the feast of Mary, Mother of God. Actually, of course, I'm happy to do it -- have to go to Mass anyway, might as well do my bit! Gordon 11:46 PM
There's been a lot of discussion at St. Blog's about this article by Pat Buchanan. Some think that Buchanan is off the deep end, and others think he's right on. I have to admit that while I've seen the figures he quotes before, to see them all together is pretty discouraging. Still, it's hard to prove that these things are necessarily the result of Vatican II. As has been blogged by me and others (see especially Jeanetta's blog) these problems are most likely the result of the hijacking of American catechesis programs and seminaries, and were not caused by the actual teachings of Vatican II. Gordon 2:13 PM
CNN reviews the new Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers and calls it a seamless triumph. I'm seeing it Friday night. I'm really jazzed about it. Gordon 11:50 AM
Tuesday, December 17, 2002
Apparently it's now open season on priests. CNN reports Jury clears man who shot priest he accused of abuse. This seems like a gross miscarriage of justice to me. I can perhaps see them acquitting him of attempted murder, but to not even find him guilty of the assault charge is going too far. The priest in question has not, to my knowledge, been convicted of anything at all. Gordon 9:49 AM
Monday, December 16, 2002
I finally got to see "My Big Fat Greek Wedding" tonight. I thought it was terrific! I can see why it's been such a popular movie. I really enjoyed the family and it was nice to see a modern movie that seems to say, yes, family can be wacky and disfunctional at times but mostly they are full of people who we love and who love us, in spite of everything. I know not everyone's family is like that, sadly. I saw a lot of my family in the movie, though. Gordon 11:53 PM
A quote for today:
"Extraordinary"? Doesn't that just mean more ordinary? Gordon 3:26 PM
A Virgin Most Pure
Lo, How a Rose E'er Blooming (instr.)
The Boar's Head Carol
Mariana Alvarado & Ted Conner, soloists
Secondi toni melodia (instr.)
God's Little Son is Born
Amber Lee Harrington, soloist
Thomas Stoltzer (c.1475-1526)
Michael Praetorius (1571-1621)
Maria durch ein' Dornwald ging
Erin Hagedon, soloist
O Jesulein süss
A solis ortus cardine
Eric Holtan & Matthew Johnson, soloists
Conditor alme siderum
(17th c. folktune)
Johann Sebastian Bach (1685-1750)
God Rest You Merry Gentlemen
Jennifer Bonds & Gordon Zaft, soloists
Matthew Johnson & Amanda Waalk, soloists
Quem pastores laudavere (instr.)
Voici la noël
Anon. (15th c.)
Anon. (16th c.)
Es ist ein Ros' entsprungen
Joseph lieber, Joseph mein
In dulci jubilo (instr.)
Herr, ich warte auf dein Heil
In dulci jubilo
Johann Walther (1496-1570)
Johann Michael Bach (1648-94)
So I got two small solos. In addition I sang the chant for Conditor Alme Siderum before the choir sang the 4-part arrangement. That's the most solos I've ever had in one concert. It was a pretty good concert, very well received. It ran about an hour and 25 minutes and the church was mostly full, which was gratifying.
To all those who have suffered from my shortcomings and mistakes I both apologize and from them beg forgiveness.
While many have called for this for a long time, I take no pleasure in a prince of the Church being driven from office. It's probably for the best, but can you imagine having to be the next bishop of Boston? Who would want it? Gordon 9:53 AM
Apologies for not blogging yesterday, I was feeling a little under the weather and stayed home from work. I'm feeling much better today. Gordon 9:44 AM
STATEMENT FROM STANFORD UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER:
Stanford University Medical Center is not engaged in human reproductive cloning. A story published Dec. 10 by the Associated Press incorrectly characterized the nature of research that would take place at the newly announced Institute for Cancer/Stem Cell Biology and Medicine at the Stanford University School of Medicine.
Creating human stem cell lines is not equivalent to reproductive cloning. The first step in the process of creating a stem cell line involves transferring the nucleus from a cell to an egg and allowing the egg to divide. This is the same first step as in reproductive cloning. However in creating a stem cell line, cells are removed from the developing cluster. These cells can go on to form many types of tissues, but cannot on their own develop into a human. Future research in this field, which will also be pursued at Stanford, will attempt to produce stem cell lines by transferring the nucleus into other embryonic stem cells rather than into eggs.
Note that this is not cloning, it's nuclear transfer in existing stem cell lines. I do find it troubling that Stanford is doing this. Still, it's not "Stanford is cloning" like some people say.
Update:This article claims that SCNT involves a form of cloning:
''Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer (SCNT) or therapeutic cloning involves removing the nucleus of an unfertilized egg cell, replacing it with the material from the nucleus of a `somatic cell' (a skin, heart, or nerve cell, for example), and stimulating this cell to begin dividing.''
Slashdot reports/discusses IBM is retiring OS/2. It's too bad. I really liked OS/2. Back in 1994 we spent a lot of time at Artisoft (now, really SpartaCom) working on LANtastic for OS/2. We really enjoyed working on OS/2, it beat the heck out of DOS and Windows. Actually, it was superior to Windows 95 in a lot of ways too. RIP, OS/2. Gordon 9:47 AM
I woke up this morning a little early because I'd been struck by the Muse. Here's what she sent me. Feedback is welcome as it's a rough draft.
The Heart... And Lower Down
What is love, and what is lust?
Green as springtime, dry as dust.
Hope that blossoms in the mist,
Ruby lips yearning to be kissed.
The labyrinth of the human heart
No mortal man can navigate
Yet in the balance lies his life,
His Love, his soul's eternal fate.
Wisdom comes with age, they say
And freedom from the stress
Of Lust's eternal siren call
Which did the heart oppress.
The future lies in shadow,
God's light does not yet shine
I'll keep the faith and carry on
And guard this heart of mine.
In the comments box on Catholic Light I commented:
I blogged about this and also responded to Jeff Miller via email, but to add further to what I said -- I agree with Brian and Bill.
Jeff's post of 1 Cor. (I thought he might be thinking of those verses but wanted to be sure) doesn't apply. It nowhere says that we should be preventing *others* from receiving unworthily, but that it is a personal responsibility. As others have said, we cannot judge the state of her soul. Those who know me know I am hardly a "squishy" Catholic, but to tell her she "should not" receive is over the line. To encourage her to go to Confession first is not. The difference is that we cannot judge whether she can receive worthily, that is up to her and her conscience. Any priest will tell you that refusing communion to someone is almost never done -- the assumption is that if the person presents himself for communion he has judged himself to be worthy to receive. Offhand the only cases I can think of where a priest might refuse communion would be someone known not to be Catholic (e.g. Bill Clinton!) or a notorious sinner (e.g. someone known to be shacking up) and even then, frankly, most priests I know would probably not refuse them but would talk to them afterward.
Eric, I'm sorry, but you are just plain wrong. You have good intentions (indeed, a few years ago I would probably have said the same thing) but you are misunderstanding mortal sin. You can't unknowingly commit a mortal sin -- it doesn't work that way. Furthermore, it's quite possible (judging by her tears) that this woman has performed the equivalent of a perfect act of contrition, in which case she would be able to receive.
One of the things I've learned (through Opus Dei mostly) is that we really need to be ready and willing to find the best interpretation/excuse for others' behavior unless we have positive proof to the contrary. In this case we might think we do, but we really don't.
Sal, keep on praying and talking.
To which Eric Johnson responded:
Gordon, I'm a little surprised that you would say I am "just plain wrong." I can assure you I know what a mortal sin is. Here's what the bishops say:
"...In order to be properly disposed to receive Communion, participants should not be conscious of grave sin and normally should have fasted for one hour. A person who is conscious of grave sin is not to receive the Body and Blood of the Lord without prior sacramental confession except for a grave reason where there is no opportunity for confession...."
You may now e-mail the bishops and tell them they're wrong to discourage Catholics -- with no provision for fallen-away Catholics -- from receiving without confession.
Another point is that few of us really know ourselves enough to say that we have given our full consent to a given action, and so if we commit an action that is objectively grave matter, we should confess first.
We seem to be playing a game of "more pastoral than thou" here, and it's getting tiresome. Let me say for the third time:
I AM NOT SAYING THAT THE FUGITIVE IS IN A STATE OF MORTAL SIN. I am not judging her soul. I am simply saying that rejecting Jesus Christ in the Eucharist is objectively a grave sin, and that it is prudent not to receive under such circumstances. This is not a novel concept.
I have no disagreement with the bishops' statement at all. Bishops have a responsibility to teach. Neither you or I is a bishop. Furthermore, I sincerely doubt any bishop would have refused this woman communion. Do you disagree?
I was not claiming that you do not know what a mortal sin is. The point is that to tell someone who is a baptized Catholic that she may not receive Communion is to judge her soul, despite your claims to the contrary. I tell people all the time not to receive Communion, but it is because they are in the RCIA and they are not Catholic. If I were a parent and I had a young child I might feel the need to tell him that, or at least to inquire. Other than that it's off limits.
I don't in the slightest dispute that we should, as a matter of prudence, go to confession before receiving Communion when we have committed a sin that is grave matter, even if we're not sure of our motivations (i.e. our conscience is not clear on whether we have mortally sinned). Indeed, this is my practice myself. We can't tell others they must make the same prudential judgment however.
The question is what should someone do in these circumstances? My point, and the point that others have made, is that it is not our place to have told this woman she should not receive Communion. In doing so we ARE judging her soul.
Again, a distinction I tried to make is that a lot depends on how we put these things. It's perfectly appropriate, IMHO, to encourage or inform -- e.g. "you may want to go to Confession first, here's a good priest I know" (this was the substance of my earlier blog on the subject). It is not okay to position ourselves as the arbiters of who is worthy or able to receive the sacraments or not, generally speaking, unless that is specifically part of our task (as in the RCIA example above, or a confessor).
I've enjoyed this discussion as it has caused me to reflect a bit about this sort of situation, which certainly does come up from time to time. Gordon 1:58 PM
Monday, December 09, 2002
Whew.... we had our final regular rehearsal for Collegium Musicum. Our concert is this Sunday at 4:30 p.m. at Northminster Presbyterian Church here in Tucson. It's free. This was a really long rehearsal. The regular rehearsal is supposed to go from 6:30 to 8:30 but it went 'til 9:30 or so, then we rehearsed our small group stuff for about a half hour, then one of the small groups I'm in rehearsed for another 10 minutes or so. I'm wiped out, that's almost 3 hrs 45 minutes of rehearsal. Plus our small group agreed to an extra rehearsal Thursday at 4:30 which is really inconvenient, but we need the extra time, so oh well... Gordon 11:45 PM
Of course, this being Slashdot, the last option in the poll is:
How I feel about the Cowboy Neal Poll Option
It's interesting to see how the geeks discuss sin. Of course, many of them dismiss the whole idea of sin. Others of them clearly don't understand what all the big words mean. In the midst, though, there are a few insights here and there. Gordon 5:12 PM
And so it begins. I once had an online diary, but even then I thought that was cheezy. I had told myself I'd never have a live journal or blog, but it would appear that I have finally caved. I'm a dork. I accept it. "Yeah, but when I do it, it's ironic!" (inside joke)
Anyone who's willing to call himself a dork in public gets my vote. Welcome to St. Blog's! Gordon 3:50 PM
I'm really sorry for the way I spoke to you at lunchtime when we were heading to Mass. It was not my intent to judge you or the state of your soul -- that's not something I can or should do. I was very happy that you were interested in going to Mass and I wanted to make sure that you were well-prepared to receive the Eucharist, our most precious treasure. As you know we need to be in the state of grace (not conscious of mortal sin) in order to receive communion, and I assumed you would need and want to go to confession beforehand. If you are interested in going to confession, I can recommend Fr. So-and-so, at St. Whatsit; he is very kind and gentle and nothing you can say will shock him. I've gone to him and he is a good confessor -- I always feel so much better after I go!
Anyway, I'm sorry for having offended you, or if I brought up bad feelings with my thoughtlessness. I hope you won't let my actions get in the way of your relationship with God.
The happiest people spend the least time alone. They pursue personal growth and intimacy; they judge themselves by their own yardsticks, never against what others do or have.
Isn't this what we've been taught all our lives? For myself, I've been thinking a lot lately about where I'm at in life. I've been making a lot of improvements in myself -- finishing school, learning to rollerblade, losing weight and eating more sensibly, and a number of other things. I honestly think I'm a much better person in many ways than I was 4 years ago. That's why it's so saddening to me that I am alone. Yes, I have my family, and some friends that mean the world to me, but still I have no one to share my life with, who loves me and cares about me and wants to be with me -- just when I think I am more lovable than ever! I try not to dwell on it but sometimes it gets me down. Gordon 2:55 PM
"There's a group of Mormon scholars, which includes me, that believe that the scientific and historical evidence against the historical claims in the Book of Mormon is so overwhelming that it's time to openly discuss the possibility of viewing the Book of Mormon as fiction, but inspired fiction," Murphy said.
For nearly 80 years, in times of calm and in times of challenge, Americans have gathered for this ceremony. The simple story we remember during this season speaks to every generation. It is the story of a quiet birth in a little town, on the margins of an indifferent empire. Yet that single event set the direction of history and still changes millions of lives. For over two millennia, Christmas has carried the message that God is with us -- and, because He's with us, we can always live in hope.
It's nice to have a non-mushy president. Gordon 11:02 AM
Sunday, December 08, 2002
Saturday we had our RCIA fall retreat. Here's the outline:
8:30 Gathering -- food, coffee etc.
9:00 Prayer (Fr. Al)
Mark tape pt. 1 (Marilyn introduces)
Mark tape pt. 2
1:00 Visualizations from Mark's Gospel (small groups)
2:00 Rite of Welcome/Acceptance intro/overview (team)
2:30 Liturgy of the Word overview & missalettes (Fr. Al)
3:00 Life timelines (small groups) (Marilyn introduces)
4:00 Liturgy of the Hours (Manolo)
The tape we watched is a tape of an Shakespearean actor (can't remember his name) who has memorized the KJV of St. Mark's Gospel and proclaims it in a very effective and memorable fashion. It's our way of making sure that even if they haven't read the gospels as we've asked them to, they are at least basically familiar with one of them.
As so often happens we wound up having to cut the life timelines because we spent more time on the small group stuff, and we also spent some time doing introductions since we had had a number of people who had joined the RCIA after we began in September. Still it was a good retreat and we accomplished a lot. Gordon 11:38 PM
Friday, December 06, 2002
The Arizona Daily Wildcat reports on grad student unrest at The University of Arizona(tm). Apparently, some Grad students may quit over tuition hike. I'm glad grad students are speaking up now. Undergrads get all the attention, but grad students comprise almost a quarter of UA students. Grad students are an important asset for the university and teach a large number of classes. Gordon 3:08 PM
In the secular world's big runup to Christmas, we often lose sight of the real person of St. Nicholas. With the recent scandals in the Church it's good to reflect on this holy bishop of Myra. St. Nicholas, pray for our bishops, and for us!
I've had my cell phone for a month today. My usage stats:
Anytime minutes used: 184 (out of 300/mo)
Night/weekend minutes used: 282 (unlimited)
PCS to PCS minutes used: 1776 (unlimited)
Yep, that's almost 30 hours of PCS to PCS yakking, about an hour a day. Wow. Clearly I have picked the right plan, though; I have plenty of time left on my anytime minutes so my monthly expenditures should be in check at $34.99/month. Gordon 1:32 PM
ATC's production was followed by a short Q&A with the cast, which was interesting. I had never seen the show before, but I'd heard the original cast album a zillion times. I was intrigued to discover that one of the original songs ("It Depends On What You Pay") was changed to "The Abduction" sometime after the show first opened. There are now two different versions of the score/script and producers can choose either one (see here for a review of an MIT production that kept the original script/score). It seems sad to me that the show should fall victim to political correctness in this way. Yes, rape is abhorrent, but that's not what the song is really about, and anyway, kidnapping is abhorrent also (I'm not going to get into trying to compare whether rape is worse than abduction). The song is really making fun of the fathers' plan to bring their children together. After all, as this review of another production points out, Man of La Mancha has a whore -- are we going to call her a "sex worker" in newer productions? Gordon 10:17 AM
In an interview with the Kuwaiti newspaper Al Siyasa, the Saudi interior minister repeated the charge, widely circulated in the Middle East, that Saudis could not have participated in the attacks because Arabs were not capable of it. Only "Zionists" could have been capable of such a feat, he said.
As soon as I read the article, I sent an email to Rainbow telling them their politics disturb me and that I will no longer be shopping at their store. The destruction of the Jews at the hands of Hitler's Nazi party, started with the boycott of jewish products. What's next? Yellow Stars of David on stores that sell jewish products? Anti-semitism scare me, and what Rainbow is doing freaks me out.
Although I slavishly admire ElfGirl, I have to say that I don't see how this is really any different, conceptually, from groups that refused to trade with South Africa during the apartheid era. I'd like to hear what others think, though. As I commented on her blog, being anti-Israel doesn't equate to being anti-semitic, at least not to me. That isn't to say that it doesn't work in the other direction, that is, presumably people who are anti-semitic would also be anti-Israel.
The root cause of this sort of issue is people's identification of Israel as speaking for all Jews, when it doesn't and can't. It's quite different from, say, Vatican City, where the Pope is the acknowledged leader of the Catholic Church and can speak for the Church in a way that, say, the prime minister of Israel cannot speak for Jews. It also points to the wisdom of the Spirit in stripping the papacy of temporal power, otherwise we Catholics might have the same sorts of issues. Gordon 4:38 PM
I know where you are coming from, friend. It is often disheartening to see the state of music in the Church, the very same Church that produced Victoria, Palestrina, Lobo, and a zillion others. I must say that I was rather surprised by this statement though:
As a music major, I had no awareness of Catholic music at all, and I've been going to Mass for as long as I can remember. Most music didn't catch my attention, especially at Cornell - it's easy to zone the drivel out at Mass when the only thing you've got on your mind is fulfilling the Sunday obligation.
I was never a music major, but as a young Catholic in high school and college I was keenly aware that much of the music we sang in our choirs was Catholic music. My high school choir did Palestrina's Sicut Cervus (albeit in English). I was very moved by it and it led me to learn a little about Palestrina and polyphonic church music in general. Still, I really started getting more acquainted with the Church's heritage of chant and polyphony only after I got my bachelor's degree and moved to California. There I joined a pretty good parish choir at Santa Clara Catholic Church in Oxnard. While it was a good (and large) choir, the music we did was mostly the OCP stuff that you find everywhere; but it was done well, and done reverently. We had a choir of 65 and we sang from the choir loft, backed by a magnificent Schoenstein organ. Between that and singing with the Ventura County Master Chorale I got an excellent background in the music of the Church.
Later, after I returned to Tucson I got to sing with the amazing Lane Justus Chorale, which for 16 years performed a capella sacred music. Though a "secular" choir, the group specialized in Renaissance polyphony. It was a great opportunity for growth and learning for me.
I'm not sure why I said all that, but to bring this back around to Aristotle's post -- most Catholics are ignorant of their faith, and that's hard to change quickly. Most Catholic musicians, even parish musicians, are ignorant of their faith AND of what the Church says about music. They only know what they've been told, and to be honest, often they've been misled or even lied to. There are many examples of this -- choirs who have been told that Vatican II says they should not sing from the loft; Vatican II says they should not sing in Latin; and so on. I recently led two workshops in my parish that I called "In the Footsteps of St. Cecilia," where I explored the spirituality of music ministry but also what the Church has said about music. I am convinced that part and parcel of the solution to the problems in liturgical music today is not just education of musicians about what Vatican II actually said; it is really, fundamentally, about a conversion of heart.
As Catholics, and musicians, and Catholic musicians, we must be more educated about our art, yes. We certainly must be both good musicians and good Catholic musicians (that is, we must have musical skills and talent and also knowledge of the liturgy and Catholic music). But fundamentally and primarily, we must be good Catholics. We must be educated, informed, dedicated, devout, reverent, committed Catholics. That is the foundation we need for all the other things, and once we are well-started on that (for of course we'll never perfect it) we can begin to apply that and our other knowledge and skills (musical and liturgical etc.) to the task of renewing and restoring Catholic liturgical music. If we don't have the foundation we won't be in touch, in tune with what we are about. Gordon 11:44 AM
Girls in reform school, people in mental institutions and poor women selected by welfare workers were among the more than 2,500 Oregonians subjected to sterilizations under a law that stood from 1917 to 1983. Gordon 3:49 PM
While you are working on your Christmas card list, take a moment to visit Operation Dear Abby.net and send a message of encouragement and support to a member of the armed forces. They deserve our prayers and support as they work for freedom and security in our world. Gordon 3:41 PM
David Morrison has blogged about the issue of priests who are too lax with penitents, so that, while they think they are being helpful they are really feeding the flock with stones instead of bread. Check it out, there's a lot of wisdom there. Gordon 1:42 PM
Joseph Scheidler vs. NOW is coming to the Supreme Court -- see Court to review abortion protests. At issue is NOW's attempt to invoke the RICO statute to stifle protests at abortion clinics. Other groups have (rightly) figured out that if this can be used against pro-lifers it can also be used against them, too. Never thought I'd see the day PETA would be filing an amicus curiae brief along with Catholic Worker houses. Gordon 1:48 PM
Mmmm.... doughnuts.... It's official -- the Star reports the first Krispy Kreme in Tucson is opening tomorrow:
Krispy Kreme Doughnuts plans to turn on its "Hot doughnuts now" sign on North Oracle Road at Auto Mall Drive at 5 a.m. Tuesday and open for business. Construction of Tucson's first outlet for the fast-growing chain is nearing completion, said franchise co-owner Jim Morrissey. A second store is planned at El Con Mall on East Broadway. Gordon 11:05 AM
More fuel for the fire -- Study: Car phone benefits equal car phone accident costs. As a newly minted cell phone owner myself I had always been annoyed when people yak and drive at the same time, even though a couple of close friends (AL, M, you know who you are) do it all the time. The irony, of course, is that I've found myself doing it as well -- mostly because I don't have as much time to talk to people as I would like. Gordon 10:17 AM
William Delmore III, an assistant district attorney in Texas, said people who don't like the law should take it up with the Texas Legislature, not courts.
He said homosexual sodomy has been considered criminal behavior for centuries. The conduct "could not conceivably have achieved the status of a fundamental right in the brief period of 16 years" since the Supreme Court last reviewed it, Delmore wrote in the state's court papers.
The last point is an interesting one. Gay rights activists will claim, presumably, that the SC's 1986 ruling was wrong and evil.
I joined the Traditional Choir for 11 a.m. Mass today.
Music for Mass First Sunday of Advent, Cycle B
Gathering Song: Maranatha (OCP)
Penitential Rite: Mass of Creation
Responsorial Psalm: Psalm 80 (Respond & Acclaim)
Gospel Acclamation: Advent Gospel Acclamation (OCP)
Preparation of the Gifts: Turn To Me (OCP)
Holy,Holy: Mass of Creation (OCP)
Memorial Acclamation: Mass of Creation (OCP)
Great Amen: Mass of Creation (OCP)
Our Father: Chant (English)
Lamb of God: Mass of Creation (OCP)
Communion: Jesu, Joy of Our Desiring (OCP)
Recessional: Sing Out, Earth and Skies (OCP)
Notice that "Jesu, Joy of Man's Desiring" has now been de-sexed to "Jesu, Joy of Our Desiring". Bleah! Oh, and I could have done without "Sing Out, Earth and Skies" (also know as the "Twinkle, Twinkle Song"). Gordon 10:46 PM
Saturday, November 30, 2002
So I attended the annual Big Game yesterday. For those not from Arizona, that's the annual day-after-Thanksgiving slugfest between the Forces of All That's Right and Just (aka the University of Arizona(tm) fighting Wildcats) and the Forces of Evil (aka the Arizona State University Sun Devils).
The Arizona Daily Star headline sums it up: Season's Grievings. It's been an awful season for the Wildcats, going into the Big Game with just one PAC-10 win (against Cal). The team lost 34-20 in a game that started out as a back-and-forth tussle that was pretty even until the fourth quarter, when the Cats started making mistakes that they couldn't turn around. Arizona fans have seen this too many times: the Wildcats too often are not able to play a full four quarters. It was just a sad game to watch. The Wildcats finish the season 4-8, their worst showing in 25 years. Star columnist Greg Hansen is insightful as always, check it out. The only bright spot of the game? Actually there are two: first, UA senior receiver Bobby Wade became UA football's record holder for receptions, a well-deserved honor. Second, unlike some nasty behavior in the past, UA and ASU fans and players behaved themselves.
I know I've blogged about it before, but I was just checking out Joe Convert's Blog. It's worth checking into from time to time -- he's a bit sporadic but his posts are worth reading. Here's a sample:
My journey into the Catholic Church isn't just an ecclesiastical change of address. It's a stark and not at all comfortable call away from practicing a form of Christianity that for me has felt safe, predictable, and not at all taxing for a long, long time. Christ invites us to partake in his suffering, to feast at his table, and to be with him in Paradise. It's all one thing; we can't pick and choose. Our adoption as sons and daughters of God is the fellowship of Christ's suffering. I still feel a closeness to God I've never experienced before, and I look forward to the day when I will know Him intimately through the Sacraments. I also know that to whom much is given, much is required. I can't pretend I don't understand what that means, and I can't un-know it. The Lord's call is not just to go to mass on Sundays and Holy Days of Obligation, say a Rosary or two, and call it good. It's the same radical message that offended the religious people of his day, as well as some of his own followers; to die to ourselves, to partake of His suffering, and to know him intimately. From the standpoint of our flesh, I suppose that's the bad news. The good news is that He's leading us on, not pushing from behind:
"For we are God's workmanship, created in Christ Jesus to do good works, which God prepared in advance for us to do." Ephesians 2:10 Gordon 5:25 PM
I cantored for our Thanksgiving Day Mass today. Hope you all have a wonderful Thanksgiving!
Music for Mass Thanksgiving Day, Cycle A
Gathering Song: For The Fruits of This Creation (OCP)
Penitential Rite: Recited
Responsorial Psalm: Psalm 67 (Respond & Acclaim Option 2)
Gospel Acclamation: Celtic Alleluia (w/verse of the day)
Preparation of the Gifts: All Good Gifts (OCP)
Holy,Holy: Mass of the Pilgrim Church (OCP)
Memorial Acclamation: Mass of the Pilgrim Church (OCP)
Great Amen: Mass of the Pilgrim Church (OCP)
Our Father: Yantis
Lamb of God: Mass of the Pilgrim Church (OCP)
Communion: Gift of Finest Wheat (OCP)
Recessional: Thanks Be To God (OCP)
Here's a really interesting article on The failure of "free love" by Frederica Mathewes-Green. She dissects how various "free love" movements have gotten our society to where it is today, and where it might be going.
Even when contraception is used, it isn’t always effective, as indicated by the other half of abortion customers. As Maggie Gallagher points out, if contraceptives properly used are 95-percent effective over a year, a sexually active woman who uses them faithfully over a 10-year period stands a 43-percent chance of getting pregnant at least once. Her chances jump dramatically if she uses them with less than exacting care. Gordon 12:07 AM
Wednesday, November 27, 2002
This is amusing... I subscribe to the Nightline daily email, which gives a heads-up on the topic for that night's edition of the ABC Nightline news program. The email for today was titled: "NIGHTLINE: Is It Deja Vous All Over Again? " Some time later I received the following followup email:
Apparently, there are a lot of you who speak French and spell it very
well. Somewhere my high school French teacher is cringing.
The title of today's Nightline email was "deja vous all over again,"
quoting the great Yogi Berra, who probably doesn't spell French very well
either. The proper spelling should have been "deja vu."
Thank you to all of the many, many, many of you who emailed us to point
out this spelling error.
Can we now say:
"Ça suffit. Nous avons bien reçu vos messages. Merci. A bientôt. ."
Sara Just and the Nightline staff
Before I go to bed, I would like to ask for prayers for my former coworker, Carol. I had dinner with Wayne, a friend and former coworker, and he mentioned to me that Carol has been diagnosed with a devastating triple whammy: lupus, fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue syndrome. Please remember her in your good prayers. Thanks. Gordon 12:17 AM
Welcome the symbols? Surely this is more than a symbol.
The song is, if you look at it, an entrance song, not a communion song. The lyrics are:
Welcome this moment, this day of sweet grace,
Welcome and enter this gathering place.
Welcome these symbols, feasting and telling;
Signs of thanksgiving, signs of indwelling.
Welcome a privilege, sister and brother,
Sharing this inbreaking light with each other.
Welcome the stranger beyond and above;
Here only friends, here only friends and beginning of love.
So the song is talking about gathering. While in the great scheme of things there's a lot to complain about this song, it is not a song primarily about the Eucharist, but about the gathered community and why it's gathered. Next...
Yet in another hymn we find only a meal, and symbols yet again:
A sign of the presence of the Lord. Is that all there is?
I agree that the song is weak, but the author is once again looking for the worst. The lyrics say that the bread and wine we offer and share are signs of grace and mercy, the (real)_presence of the Lord. What does she want, a discourse on the theology of transubstantiation? Next...
Similarly, in "Bread, Blessed and Broken" we find no reference to Body, Blood, Presence, or sacrifice:
But the full lyric is "Give us to drink the wine of compassion, give us to eat the bread that is You." That sounds a bit different than she makes it sound. And again, the song is not meant as a communion song or a hymn to the Eucharist, but as a gathering song. Next...
Bread is re-birth, wine is compassion? They may be something else again, as in this hymn:
Of course, that is the first half of the very last verse. The last half of the verse:
broken now for your people,
poured in endless love.
The refrain is better:
Bread of life, hope for the world,
Jesus Christ, our brother;
feed us now, give us life,
lead us to one another.
Although why we need to be led to one another beats me; we need to be led to Christ.
I'd go on, but this is long enough. My main point is not that there are not some weak and even objectionable songs (there are), but rather that the author's lyric quotations are sometimes misleading and unfair at times. Gordon 3:31 PM
A nice article about St. Blog's on Catholic Exchange -- Got Blog?. Gordon 1:12 PM
Nationwide, one-third of people ages 18 to 29 said abortion should never be legal. That contrasts with about 23 percent for those ages 30 to 64, and about 20 percent for those over age 65. Gordon 4:03 PM
Okay, I've been holding off blogging about this until I had a little more time, which more or less seems to be now. Last week I became aware (in the course of a casual conversation) that a(nother) parish here in the Diocese of Tucson is postponing First Confessions for kids coming through their sacraments program. Specifically, they do First Communion in 1st grade (or maybe 2nd) and First Confession not until 4th grade (!). Oh sure, there's some disclaimer that if parents really want their kids to make their First Confession prior to First Communion that Arrangements Can Be Made. Still, everything I've read says that the norm, the default, the standard practice is confession and then Eucharist. Duh. These are the same people that then go on to wonder why people don't go to Confession anymore. It's because the kids don't make the connection because they've not been prepared adequately!
My question is, what if anything should I do? I asked a friend in the diocese and she advised me to leave it alone as nothing I can do will make a difference anyway. She's probably right about that -- it seems a bit much to assume that our bishops are ignorant of the situation, and the pastor presumably either wanted it this way (seems most likely) or aquiesced (possible, but from what I know not likely). So, dear reader -- what do you think? A letter to the pastor? A letter to the bishop? Nothing? Well, prayer at least I suppose.
Canon 914. It is the responsibility, in the first place, of parents and those who take the place of parents as well as of the pastor to see that children who have reached the use of reason are correctly prepared and are nourished by the divine food as early as possible, preceded by sacramental confession; it is also for the pastor to be vigilant lest any children come to the Holy Banquet who have not reached the use of reason or whom he judges are not sufficiently disposed.
Mark Shea is a treasure. Check out his post on press bias toward the Church. I particularly like this:
What strange power the Church has. It cannot keep the world from committing promiscuity and fornication and homosexual acts on a daily basis, but by some weird magic, all the people doing these things are petrified of using a condom because of the Church. Meanwhile, the only serious way to avoid infection is (surprise!) the way the Church urges: by heeding its teaching on sexual morality and drug use. Gordon 1:37 PM
Sunday, November 24, 2002
Last night I went to the UA Opera Theater production of "Die Fledermaus." DF is one of my favorite operas and UA's production was pretty good. In particular, the 3rd act was probably the funniest I've ever seen, bar none. The audience was just rolling in the aisles, it was so good.
The male lead (Eisenstein) was played by Todd Strange. He was excellent. After the show I got a chance to greet and congratulate him. Todd is a brother of mine in Phi Mu Alpha Sinfonia, a men's music fraternity founded in 1898. It's good to see members of our fraternity living out our values in the work they do. I think he will go far; he is very talented. Gordon 11:48 PM
My personal musings on God, the Church, computers, music, and whatever else comes to mind.